Grade Level

9 - 12

Purpose

Students observe soil ecosystems to investigate how human impact affects the biodiversity of soils using the Simpson's Index of Diversity. Then, students conduct an investigation using field corn to determine how the introduction of nitrogen fertilizers impact soil microorganisms and biodiversity. Grades 9-12

Estimated Time

Two investigations using 2-3 class periods each plus observation time

Materials Needed

Engage:

• About 1L of soil of each type of soil described below
  • Soil that has been dried. (The dried soil may be left out to air dry or dried in a drying oven.)
  • Soil that has been freshly collected from a planted area.
  • Soil that has been collected from a non-planted area.

Activity 1: Mesofauna Biodiversity Investigation

• Mesofauna Biodiversity Investigation student handout, 1 copy per student
• Per Student Group:
  • Soil samples (Human impacted ecosystem and natural ecosystem)
  • 2, 1 gallon zip lock bags
  • 2, 2-L bottles to create Berlese Funnel
  • Scissors
  • Duct tape
  • Scale
  • Ruler or tape measure
  • Wire screen or mesh screen
  • Isopropyl alcohol
  • Dissecting microscope or magnifying glass
  • Small jar with tight fitting lid
  • Petri dish
  • Heat lamp

Activity 2: Soil, Microbes, and Plants

• Soil, Microbes, and Plants student handout, 1 copy per student
• Soil
  • Corn can be grown in soil found outside your classroom or home or in a potting soil mix. However, it is important to purchase a potting soil mix that does not already have fertilizer blended into it. Corn will grow best in a greenhouse or sunlit area that can assure that the soil will stay at or above 21° C. 
• 3, 2-L bottles (cut in half) per group
• Field (dent) corn seed
• Fertilizer containing nitrogen (urea)
  • You can find urea at your local garden store or farmer co-op. Urea can be used as a dry time-release fertilizer if sprinkled around the base of a plant, or as a liquid fertilizer by mixing 113 grams of urea to 1.9 liters of water resulting in a 28-0-0 solution.
• Nitrogen-fixing microbial soil amendment such as CisBay
  • Locate a microbial product that adds nitrogen-fixing bacteria to the soil for student use. There are several agricultural companies that provide products that maximize nitrogen availability to plants, such as CisBay. 
• Soil nitrogen tests

Vocabulary

Did You Know?

• 1 tablespoon of soil has more organisms in it than there are people on earth.¹
• The kind of corn we eat is called 'sweet corn.' Corn that is produced for other purposes is called 'field' corn or 'dent' corn.²
• Corn is one of the top grain commodities in the U.S. It is harvested to make many different products such as feed for animals, starch, sweeteners, and ethanol fuel.²

Background Agricultural Connections

Systems thinking has been used to describe ecosystems and various processes in agriculture and the environment for a long time. Systems thinking can be described as looking at the interconnected parts of a whole. Each part can be labeled as one of four aspects: inputs, things that are added to the system from outside the system; outputs, the things produced from the system; storages, the places where some of the inputs are incorporated, or stored for future use; and flows, the movement of the matter and energy between the parts. Each one of these aspects is usually balanced by another in order for the system to maintain equilibrium or to stay in balance.

Agriculture is such a system. In order to produce agricultural products (crops, livestock feed, livestock, fuel), there are inputs that must be used. These inputs include seeds, nutrients from fertilizers, pesticides, water, the equipment to plant, as well as the fuel to power the equipment. Some of these are incorporated into the products, but some are not available to the product due to timing, or other environmental factors, such as rain or lack of rain, temperature, or plant development. These inputs then flow from one place to another within the agricultural system or they leave the system before they can be utilized. Some of these inputs are stored within the particles of soil and therefore have a better chance to be used or become part of the product. Soil is a large storage within the agriculture system.

Three particles that make up soil are sand, silt and clay. These sediments are weathered from surface rocks or eroded by water or wind and carried to other places. Soil has varying levels of porosity and permeability depending on the structure and texture, allowing it to help or hinder plant growth. The texture of the soil will determine how well it will hold water and nutrients. Soil stability or structure helps soil withstand erosion and allow for water infiltration.

The three main soil nutrients include Nitrogen, Phosphorus and Potassium. These are abbreviated as N, P, and K. Nitrogen helps to maximize the photosynthetic ability of the corn plant and increase yield potential. Phosphorus is important for flowering and root growth. Potassium is necessary to prevent water loss and aids in photosynthesis. The mineral content can affect the ability for certain plants to grow better than others. pH is another important quality in soils. It refers to the level of Hydrogen ions in the soil. Depending on the amount of Hydrogen ions, soil can be neutral, acidic or basic. Too much acidity or basicity can affect the plant’s ability to draw nutrients from the soil.

The soil texture, structure, nutrients, pH and mineral content will be important for whatever plant is planted. Depending on the soil characteristics, growers may add amendments in the form of nutrients, pesticides, and water. The consequences of overuse of one of these soil amendments, fertilizers, center primarily on a problem called cultural eutrophication. When nutrients are applied in quantities that cannot be stored or assimilated by plants, or when there is an event that causes them to run-off, they find their way into local water sources. Once in the water source, the phytoplankton and algae that naturally live there begin to bloom. Some of this algae can give off toxins that can cause illness in people or animals. The bloom can entirely cover the surface and grow several layers thick depending on the amount of input. When the algae or phytoplankton die, many bacteria are needed to decompose them, thereby depleting the water of dissolved oxygen. This results in what is commonly referred to as a “dead zone.” Fish and other aquatic life cannot live there since the oxygen levels are depleted. (See Water quality.)

Soil plays a very important role in the system of agricultural inputs, outputs, storages and flows.

Mesofauna are defined as very small invertebrate animals that live in or on soil on benthic sediment, referred to as ‘leaf litter’ in this experiment. Leaf litter cover plays a protective role in resisting soil erosion due to rainfall. This protection is removed as litter decomposes. The protective effect is influenced by the presence or absence of soil meso- and macrofauna. Fauna in the leaf litter help to decompose the organic matter, releasing nutrients for flora use and aid in soil aggregation and porosity.

Biodiversity is important because the more diverse the different roles (producers, consumers, and decomposers) found within the ecosystem, the more the ecosystem can maintain stability. The greater the biodiversity in an ecosystem, the more healthy and stable the ecosystem is. The healthier an ecosystem is, the longer the ecosystem can exist in nature.

Agricultural tillage practices vary greatly across the world in preparation for growing crops. Students will research soil ecosystems that are both disturbed by human impact (conventionally tilled) and undisturbed by human impact (no tillage) in this investigation. Human impact is greatest when conventional tillage is employed. Tillage breaks up soil structure, destroys residue on the soil’s surface and aids in soil compaction. No-till practices promote a higher water retention, reduce soil erosion, increase soil biological activity and increase soil organic matter. (usda.gov)

Students will use Simpson’s Index of Diversity to determine the level of biodiversity present in soil ecosystems. Simpson’s Index of Diversity is a measure of diversity that incorporates information about species richness, as well as the relative abundance (species evenness) of each species in the community. Species richness is the number of species per sample, whereas relative abundance compares the number of organisms of a species with the total number of organisms found in the sample. As species richness and evenness increase, then ecosystem diversity will increase. The Simpson’s Index of Diversity value (D) ranges between 0 and 1. In Simpson’s Index of Diversity, 1 represents infinite diversity and 0, no diversity. 

Activity 2 will ask students to evaluate the claim that nitrogen amendments in modern agricultural practices impact the stability of soil ecosystems. The three major nutrients found in soil are nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and potassium (K). Bacteria and other microorganisms in the soil allow for nitrogen fixation to happen (unusable atmospheric nitrogen is converted into usable nitrogen for the plant) and can increase nitrogen levels in the soil. This is an important part of the nitrogen cycle for plants and in many cases what limits the growth of producers.

Nitrogen makes up approximately 77% of our atmosphere. This form of nitrogen is of no value to plants and animals. Nitrogen gas (N2) is captured from the air by species of bacteria and is made into nitrates (NO3-). Nitrogen then enters the food web when plants absorb those nitrates and make proteins, an essential macromolecule to animals. Consumers get the nitrogen by eating plants or other animals that contain nitrogen. They reuse the nitrogen and make their own proteins. In addition to this, nitrogen can be returned to the soil when an animal urinates or when an organism dies and decomposers go to work, in the form of ammonia (NH3). Other organisms in the soil can convert ammonia into usable nitrogen compounds that will re-enter the food web. When ammonium (NH4+) is added to the soil as a fertilizer or by bacteria converting atmospheric nitrogen, it can be converted into nitrites (NO2-) and again into nitrates by different species of bacteria.

Nitrogen within a plant aids in its growth and development. Plants that lack nitrogen appear yellow, do not grow as well, and produce lower yields. When plants are given enough nitrogen, they are able to produce the proteins that help them to grow. One of the specific things nitrogen can do for a plant is help with the production of chlorophyll. The more chlorophyll that a plant has, the more efficient it can be in conducting photosynthesis and the more food it can make. The photosynthetic reactions occurring in their leaves are then used to produce chemicals, known as exudate, which they secrete through their roots. Root exudates are in the form of carbohydrates and proteins. Their presence in the soil wakes up, attracts, and grows specific beneficial bacteria and fungi that subsist on these exudates and the cellular materials sloughed off as the plant’s root tips grow. These interactions between microorganisms and plants help to maintain soil structure, nutrient availability, and ecosystem stability.

Some bacteria have lessened or stopped going through nitrogen fixation altogether due to additional amounts of nitrogen added to the soil. Generally, if farmers want to get more nitrogen into the ground they need to rotate their crops. Farmers will make sure to plant crops (legumes) that will help return nitrogen levels after planting a crop that has removed a lot of nitrogen from the  soil. Farmers also can add nitrogen to the soil through the application of fertilizers. Farmers need to be careful to apply the correct amount of fertilizer at the appropriate time so they can maximize yields and minimize leaching and eutrophication. Runoff from agricultural fields can contain excess nutrients, not assimilated by plants, that enter into surrounding watersheds. Nitrates (NO3-), the most usable form of nitrogen by plants, are also the most prone to leaching (drain away from soil with percolating water) and possible eutrophication of water systems. Nitrates support freshwater eutrophication (an excessive amount of nutrients in water systems that supports algae growth), but are secondary to phosphorus, the limiting factor in freshwater algal blooms. How can the addition of nitrogen impact soil ecosystems?

Engage

1. Prior to class, collect three soil samples described below. About 1L of soil of each type should be enough for the class.
   • Soil that has been dried. (The dried soil may be left out to air dry or dried in a drying oven.)
   • Soil that has been freshly collected from a planted area.
   • Soil that has been collected from a non-planted area.
2. Provide the claim “soil is alive” to students as you pass some freshly-dug soil and dehydrated (completely dry) soil samples around for the students to observe. If you do not have access to fresh and dehydrated soils, show them some images such as these (image 1, image 2): 
3. Ask students to brainstorm evidence to support or refute the claim statement individually for one minute, then share their evidence within small groups (three or four students) for two to three minutes.
4. Have groups share their evidence one by one with the large group until all are shared and recorded. Create an evidence board to keep track of the data provided by students as you lead the discussion.
5. Brainstorm the characteristics of living things with the students and add them to the board.
6. Ask students to organize the individual pieces of evidence on the board into reasoning statements that support or refute the claim “soil is alive.”
7. To begin investigating this claim, have students brainstorm ways they might test their claims by planning and conducting investigations.

Explore and Explain

Activity 1: Mesofauna Biodiversity Investigation
Can human impact affect the biodiversity of soils? How can Simpson's Index of Diversity help to determine the species richness of disturbed soils?

Teacher Preparation:

• Determine where students can collect soil samples or ask students to bring in samples from home. Each sample should fill one quart-sized bag.
• Collect 2-liter bottles prior to the investigation. There should be one 2-liter bottle per soil sample.
• Provide students with dichotomous keys or ID books for identification of mesofauna.

Procedures:

1. Give each student one copy of the Mesofauna Biodiversity Investigation student handout.
2. Review the handout with students and provide access to the supplies listed in the Materials section of the lesson.
3. Suggested timing:
   • Day 1: Soil collection demonstration (have students collect samples for homework. Use soil samples from local farms with various tillage techniques.
   • Day 2: Set up Berlese funnels
   • Day 3: Data collection
4. Refer to the Mesofauna Biodiversity Investigation—Key to find options for differentiation in the classroom, answers to the reflection questions, and a rubric to evaluate the assessment.

Activity 2: Soil, Microbes, and Plants
What are the relationships between soil microorganisms such as nitrogen-fixing bacteria and plants? Has the introduction of nitrogen fertilizers into soil ecosystems impacted the populations of soil microorganisms? How can we maximize corn growth while limiting fertilizer use? 

Teacher Preparation:

• This lab will take approximately 4–5 weeks to complete.
• 1 to 3 class periods should be made available to students to research the role of nitrifying bacteria within the soil ecosystem and the human impact of fertilizer into an ecosystem.
• Students will need 1 class period to design their investigation and 1 day to prepare the experiment.
• 3–4 weeks will be needed to measure plant growth and measure nitrogen levels.
• Students will collect data throughout this time and will need 1 day to report their findings back to the class.

Procedures:

1. Give each student one copy of the Soil, Microbes, and Plants student handout.
2. Review the handout with students and provide access to the supplies they can use to carry out their investigation.
3. Refer to the Soil, Microbes, and Plants—Key to find options for differentiation in the classroom and a rubric to evaluate the assessment.

Elaborate

Evaluate

After completing these activites, review and summarize the following key concepts:

• Soil is the basis for farming. A healthy soil system will produce crops sustainably for years and years.
• Soil is an ecosystem composed of living organisms.
• Soil health is one element of environmental sustainability.

Sources

1. https://www.audubon.org/news/10-incredible-facts-about-dirt
2. https://americasheartland.org/commodities/corn.htm

Acknowledgements

This lesson is from the Soil and Sustainability unit created by Nourish the Future.

Recommended Companion Resources

• Dirt: The Scoop on Soil
• Living Soil Film
• Move 'N Around – The Nitrogen Cycle Game
• Soil Health Education Resources
• Soil Science Society of America
• SoilWeb Interactive Map

Author

Nourish the Future

Organization

Nourish the Future